Extraction shooters are a very demanding genre to engage in.

It's in part due to their PvP focused nature, in another part is due to the ephemeral nature of the progression system, in a smaller but much stronger part... the social aspect seems interesting from a distance but scary up close.

But despite all of these issues, I found myself pulled into Marathon due to it finally being another shooter from Bungie. I said it many times before and I want it to be said here, the day Bungie makes a bad shooter the world ends.

So I gave it a shot since a lot of my friends were giving it a genuine try and I wanted to experience an extraction shooter to it's fullest. I fell in love with the world, the lore and the aesthetics, it screamed with a unique twist on trans-humanism, oppressive capitalism and sci-fi shenanigans and every inch of the world that I got to explore on my journey during Season 1 and 2 was captivating. It would not be an exaggeration to say that part of the reason I found myself queuing into more and more matches was the visuals, sounds and lore alone.

[Source for pictures: Reddit post by u/upstate_0]

Entryway for a tunnel on the map Dire Marsh, the building is a deep blue while the door itself is yellow. The area seems covered in fog.
A building on the map Dire Marsh, the building is deep blue, with other externals parts like the door is yellow. There is a yellow truck outside. The area around the building is a lush dark brown scenery.
A Building in the map Dire Marsh, the area is a swamp and the building itself is a pinkish red, the sky is visible with both a planet and a moon above it.
A Building in Dire Marsh, the building is red and white, resembling a loading dock, in the sky you can see the planet, a moon and the titular ship, the Marathon, floating around the moon
A corridor in a building, the building is a very light teal and there are scattered tech equipment scattered like a maintenance corridor, the area must have access to the sky since there seems to be sunlight coming from the top
A Maintenance corridor, with heavy tubes and ventilation shafts following the path, the entire area is bathed in a red light, with limited visibility.

Then came the gunplay.

Holy fuck the gunplay.

Again, Bungie can't make a shooter that the moment to moment gameplay does not partake of a honed edge that puts other shooters to shame and Marathon is no different. Every gun, every shot, every engagement (Even with the bots) is blood pumping, immersive and engaging,

I though the hero shooter aspect of the characters would make for a less interesting interaction and I was happily wrong there, every character plays different and incentivizes play-styles that I was able to find some level of joy to play as. (Except Assassin, never really clicked there but watching a good assassin player is a delicious sight)

All these aspects make for a good game. But not a perfect game...

Wallpaper depicting Vandal, her silhouette is mixing the background as both are colored colored with darker and lighter tones mixed in. She is also glowing a very bright red in her face and eyes, making a finger gun pointed at the center of the screen

The progression, despite being an extraction shooter still felt weird and slow. When I started, stats were extremely painful to acquire and the contracts that gave meaningful rewards were... oddly hard to execute as a solo queue player. The few matches I got with friends were fun and it was interesting loading into a map and slowly learning how to complete each goal for each member of my crew, but it made defeats taste a bit sour.

Death is part of the cycle, that's something that Marathon drills into you early, but the non-persistent nature from the items that I got from partaking in this loop did make for a game that self-set goals were hard or vague to accomplish.

Yes, I could work on getting VIP with one (Or all) factions, but the grind at Season 1 was rough and while Season 2 was much better it was still relatively simple and direct

Yes, I could gear myself up slowly or as fast as I could to start taking on the Cryo Archive. But again, Solo queuing into it was... a mixed bag. Some crews were phenomenal, other crews made me question why they chose Squad Fill if this was the standard of play I was expected to perform at.

I wanted to fight the Compiler on PvP Cryo, but that one... that one never came true as my friends lost a lot of interest in the objective and map due to balancing issues. And my social anxiety cock blocked me of meeting new people that could help achieve that goal.

So for a game with deliciously dense and satisfying content, I was unable to partake on a solid chunk of it due a mixture of odd balancing, lack of friends/unfriendly solo environment and my own lack of skill with the game.

I wanted to dive in more and more into what the game had to offer, the world and it's aggressively captivating maps and scenery, the lore sprinkled with care around that even finding a liquid cheeseburger was an exciting discovery, and gunplay that scratched an itch that classic Halo and Destiny could not.

But the genre the game originated from, so crucial to it's DNA, so ingrained in the design of the systems, world and flow of gameplay... I hate to say it, it pushed me away hard. And yet, the pull was stronger for a while. My work breaks were loading into a match and seeing what would happen, no goal or grand objective, I just wanted to be IN the match.

But, unfortunately, that level of interest did not persist for long. And when it fizzled, it very much saddened me.

A Image of Vandal, the is sitting atop a building looking far into the horizon, she is located on the right side of the screen. The rest of the image is of a cloudy, grey sky

Experiments for something different, hoping for the best.

Apparently, I wasn't the only one feeling like this and the number for adoption and player base for the game weren't the best. Based on this, Bungie decided to act.

One of the first things they did, come Season 2, was start experimenting with modes that tried to address the level of commitment with the PvP modes, a PvPvE mode and a full-on PvE mode.

For PvP modes, they used Sponsored Modes. This forces everyone runner to join the match with a Sponsored Kit, usually the most basic one, to do a run. This creates a sort of equilibrium when it comes to gear, so usually in a gun fight you're bound to fight people with similar weaponry, leveling the playing field a lot. I played many matches on these modes and they are fun, but just playing them does not make much sense. Besides the materials for progressing my factions, why the hell won't I use do runs outside of this mode to use some of the gear I am earning from it? It helped, but not a lot as I still was not super motivated to go from the low risk of Sponsored into the high risk of normal matches.

For PvPvE there was Sponsored Survival, only one team matches up to the map, they cannot extract until the very final extraction, once the run timer runs out completely, and the only other players on the maps are the one crew and any and all rooks (Solo players that need to use a very weak character that acts as scavengers). Usually, I never see rooks on these maps, since there is only extraction, so it basically was the maps, but no players. A PvE mode by accident.

I liked it, a lot. It let me experience things on the map that I could've only dreamed of in normal matches due to the fear of better equipped players jumping us while we work on a major map goal. It lacked the sharp sense of danger and fear, but I ended up not minding it as much since I felt that the bots were plenty deadly. The time limit also kept things going on a good pace since it clearly set a timeline for the match.

And lastly, for PvE... we have the big one. Vaultbreaker

Vaultbreaker runs on the game's biggest and most complex map, the Cryo Archive. Before I talk about what makes Vaultbreaker the mode it is, I need to talk about Cryo itself

Cryo Archive: The good, the bad and the cold.

When the game originally launched, the 3 maps were just Perimeter, Dire Marsh and Complex. But people quickly found an ARG spread around the game and some websites. The ARG itself was super long and very par for the course when it came to Bungie.

This fourth map is special for a lot of reasons, the location itself is on the ship carrying the game's name, it is the last map you unlock on your level progression, it is the only map that demands your kit to have a minimum total value to even enter, and it has the single highest density of activities to do in a single map (alongside being the biggest and most complex map in the entire game).

It is, on a design and technical level, the game's best map. Not only is it filled with secrets, lore and challenges it contains the game one and only boss fight.

You read it right, a Boss Fight, in a PvP game.

An image of the Control area of the map Cryo Archive. The area is bathed in a pale light with the Panopticon sitting atop the center of the image with gigantic ribbon-style cables coming from the ceiling. You can see a catwalk where the picture was taken

The way it works is that the map is filled with 7 vaults, that can only be opened if you have all the components necessary to bypass the security. But it always starts with one specific item: A Cryo Archive Key.

While doing other content in the game, you may come across a Cryo Archive key, these are numbered 1 through 6. These keys are the first step to opening a vault inside the Cryo Archive map itself, but they are not the only step you need to take.

Once you load into a match inside the Cryo Archive, you need to find the vault entrance and figure out what else that door needs to open.

Some doors only require a specific numbers of batteries to open, others also need cryogenic fluid to go along. Others have entire puzzles involving knocking down preserved colonists bodies, sampling their DNA to create an access-card that you can then use alongside previously mentioned key, batteries and fluid to open a single vault door.

The steps can be complex and necessitate a lot of walking and fighting your way through the Archive and the PvE enemies constantly spawning around the area. And you have to do ALL OF THAT while OTHER PLAYERS are around and can 100% kill you, blocking you from making progress and stealing it from you, reaping the rewards from your cold dead body.

It is a situation where the stakes are through the roof, there is always tension when you load into Cryo Archive and decide to do a vault. But the rewards match the risk, clearly.

Now, if you notice I mentioned early that there are 7 vaults, but I said you can find keys 1 to 6. That's because our target is in Vault 7 and to access that vault you need to complete all 6 other vaults and collect an item inside, then exfill with said item in your inventory.

Once you do this with all 6 items, you can collect a sort of check mark for your account in your "challenges" that unlocks the possibility to do Vault 7.

A picture of the Compiler, his frame looks like a hooded and robed man, with large shoulder and a green orb lodged to his chest. The surrounding area seems to be a storage area bathed in red light.

This vault can only be opened by finding a DNA Access Card inside any previous vault and starting a long, grueling process that has you running around multiple areas of the Cryo Archive, solving puzzles, killing mini bosses and accessing locked down areas that actively harm you unless you have specific counter measures in your bag. And, need I remind you, with OTHER PLAYERS potentially looking to intercept and take everything from you.

But at the end of that long quest inside the map, you find a long winded passage where you will face the Compiler. This functions like a mini-raid encounter from Destiny, it has mechanics, damage phases and even a fail state that requires your team to be heavily prepared and coordinated to win it, but if you are able to bring the boss down you get unique cosmetics that serve as a bragging right, incredible loot and a personal escape route out of the map with all you can carry.

It is the pinnacle of the challenge in Marathon and it was one my personal goals to achieve.

Alas, it never came to be. For all the reasons I mentioned earlier. Thus this created a very unique problem.

The best content in the game, the Cryo Archive and the Compiler, were never really accessible to players like me who could not ascend to the high levels of dedication, execution and the good team that was necessary to win. And as such there was a chance we would never experience that grueling, blood pumping and intense race to crack the vault and face the alien monster laying inside the Marathon.

Vaultbreaker, proposed a solution to the inaccessibility

Vaultbreaker: Similar and yet different

The idea is to offer a PvE experience by creating a time trial, where the ultimate goal is to fight the Compiler.

Promotional picture of the Vaultbreaker mode, with the text "Vaultbreaker - Experimental PVE Mode - Season 2 - V1.1.5" The picture shows the character Thief in the area of the Cryo Archive map known as Control, surrounded in fog.

The game spawns you in the map with a specific loadout that you upgrade with currency you get from doing this game mode, as soon as you load in, you get a random key between vaults 1 and 2. The next step? Open said vault to get the next key. The idea is that you need to complete 3 vaults before given the first step in the chain to fight the compiler, all under one single instance of 35 minutes. The only players in the instance are you and your two other team mates, but where the PvP tension was, there is now a Time Limit tension.

In 35 minutes you need to crack 3 vaults from 1 to 6, in a random ascending order, before being given the 7th vault access and then you also need to complete the most complex vault and the Compiler fight itself before being able to consider a Vaultbreaker run as a full run.

You don't need to fight against the boss to complete the run, you can loot however many vaults you can and extract, but the only rewards are currency that you can then upgrade your loadout to go back in. A Roguelite version of the best content and map in the game, without the PvP tension.

And honestly? It works.

It is not the same, the tension and the atmosphere are nowhere near the same as normal Cryo, but what is here is a genuine iterative loop where run by run, you get better at completing vaults, optimizing routes, collecting resources, looting and everything that Marathon has been asking of you in this one run to fight the Compiler.

It's different, but similar enough that it worked just as much and people like me, who had no hope of conquering the PvP version of Cryo Archive, had a chance to experience some of that thrill.

It also proved that Marathon could change to become more interesting to a audience beyond the extraction player shooter.

It is a good thing, because if the game wishes to survive the drought it currently faces, it needs to adapt and bring new players in. But a good chunk of the original sauce that kept me playing Marathon on the start is at risk of being lost or diluted, and I don't know what that means for the future of the game.

Speaking of said future...

Uncertainty on the horizon

In December, Marathon takes the first step to change. It will introduce the game's first permanent PvE mode, as well as the first several changes, and experiments to the game's PvPvE nature.

Promotional picture of the new boss, the Tick Queen. Four players are fighting it, shooting at it or pointing their weaponry at it. The monster itself is screaming at its opponents. The area is bathed is a pinkish light and is heavily distorted due to all the combat around.

The idea is to go beyond the extraction game mode but not abandon it entirely, it's aiming to create a game where if you're looking for a calmer experience go play mode A, want the classical extraction? Play mode B, want to find middle ground? Maybe try the experimental team death-match mode.

While I think the game can and needs to evolve beyond it's extraction shooter origins, I fear that this exploration of what might work inside this brutal and immersive world may be the exact thing that ruins it. But this is a game series I genuinely just parachuted in, I don't know if I really get the game and the series enough to be able to know what makes the current iteration of the game tick. But still, I can't deny that it does need to change.

So while I have reservations and still feel uneasy, I can only look at the future and hope for the best.

A picture of the new version of Perimeter. In the center of the screen is the Exfill device, shooting a laser to the sky. The rest of the area is bathed in a fungal mist, with dead tress and fungal growths sprouting from the ground in red and white hues.

For what it is worth, Symbiosis looks promising and while fighting a giant tick monster isn't nearly the same feeling as fighting the Compiler and I have 0 idea of how a TDM Game Mode would even function and be 10% as intriguing as the current modes, I have to believe they would figure out a way. And given the recent second wind (Tenth wind? I lost count at this point) the studio got after Destiny's "end of service" it may just as well be possible that the coming days of Marathon will be far brighter than anything I could've predicted.