Spoiler Warning - Final Fantasy XIV Dawntrail

As part of my thoughts, I'll be talking about spoilers for FF XIV's current expansion, Dawntrail, specifically the themes and visual of the last area.


During Dawntrail's main story, we visit a place called 'Living Memory'. This area is themed around Death and Avoidance; people who die come here and "live" on as Endless, memories given form with eternal, and apparently, perfect lives.

The songs and visuals of the place when you first visit have this odd taste of a veiled calm, the entire cityscape is bathed in golden light that fakes warmth with a general theme park structure. It's almost like the dead people that "live" here are set up as some sort of museum or workers in a tourist family's vacation park.

A high-tech cityscape from Final Fantasy XIV, called living memory. In the center stands a tower where a female looking person is carved into it. The entire area is bathed in golden light, the sky is also bathed in gold light

Even the song sounds happy but melancholic. Happy but also not, hypocritical in nature but nostalgic in comfort. It is the entire point of the main conflict of the zone: the hypocrisy of denying death and choosing to live in comforting nostalgia.

While the story makes good points about the finality of mortality and legacies, the thing that stuck with me was that despite living seemingly perfect lives, some of the people in this realm seemed to be faking said blissful happiness.

Later on, it's discovered that they seem that way because ultimately, they aren't really alive. It's sort of a talking computer that emulates the person whose memory it represents. It's what I feel AI bros want to do with ChatGPT and its derivatives. (Which is an entirely separate can of worms that I don't feel like I have the eloquence or philosophy know-how to write about)

A "simulacrum" of what it was to be alive, in the best moment of your life. Trapped in the nostalgia of a life well lived, without the pain and suffering of the unachieved.

Now that simple detail, that fake joy, is what attached me the most to this part of the game. Because sometimes I didn't know if I was faking it like them.


One of the many things I tried in therapy was learning how to love myself, part of the exercise I was given was to find things that I liked about myself. Problem is, I came up empty.

As a follow-up, I was told to try thinking of things others liked in me. I... Also came up empty there.

That second time, it felt weird. I heard compliments before; I know there are things people like in me. But when prompted to name them, my brain didn't even remember what it heard.

Why?

I like hearing compliments. Why can't I remember them? It's almost like my head doesn't want to remember, or it refuses to.

I struggled with those questions a lot, and in the end, I feel the answer was always in my face. I simply did not know how to voice it.

I didn't believe in them. It was that simple.

I was told that I was a good friend, but good friends aren't distant or so incapable of sparing attention that they don't pay attention to what you're saying. I was told I was good at fighting games, but I was always mediocre at best. I was told I give good advice, and yet I can't follow it most of the time, and I doubt any advice I give out of fear of something going wrong.

For every good thing, there was always a comma, a but, an interjection, proof of my failure.

I heard the compliments, I liked living in the short relief of comfort they brought before my head convinced me that I was undeserving of them. But as soon as I was swayed from believing the words being said with love and care towards me, they left my memory.

And yet, I acted as if they meant something. After all, I don't want to hurt the person speaking said words. I didn't deserve the words, but I could not ignore them and risk hurting people I love.

Seeing a character act out that fakeness, with a different context and to a different extreme, it didn't matter that some were more aware of their simulated origin than others. It made me realize that despite years of therapy... I still don't know how to love myself.

Concept art for Living Memory, depicting the 4 districts based on the colors blue, purple, green, and red, with the female statue in the center. Gold light is still the single most prevalent color in the picture.

In-game, eventually, due to the story, you learn that the simulacra, in some ways, want to be let go, and, as part of your goal to stop another catastrophe, you need to shut down the computers that power these memories from existing physically. So things align, and you power down each section of the city with the goal of weakening the big bad of the current moment.

When you do so, the city finally gets a proper sky, but everything else in the city loses that gold shimmer, the illusion is shattered, and you feel like you're walking through a graveyard. The music now plays with alternating volume, like a distant memory that you can't live in anymore. It's perfect for the message of the game, and it was the zone that I just... walked around in whenever I found myself hanging about the area.

The same cityscape, with clear skies. The golden light is gone and left behing are the colorful tree and the blackened structures devoid of life.

There's a lot here. Melancholy, regret, pain, nostalgia, quiet happiness... It is one of my favorite zones in the entire game, but I can't stay in it for long because of the headspace it puts me in.

It... kind of hits too close to home. It consistently reminds me of my own struggles, not just in "simple things" like loving myself.

The soundtrack, "Echoes of Memory", serves as music I listen to when all I can think about is the regrets, the dreams I never achieved, the hobbies abandoned, the friends I didn't hear from, the words I didn't say...

I hear from my boss that I am dedicated and hard-working. Yet I struggle to do basic tasks, and that also applies to my personal goals like writing and music. I lack consistency and often drift away from passions like a raft without a sail, taken by the waves.

I guess it's ADHD, but I don't like saying that because... There are people out there who can do all of these things despite the condition. What's my excuse?

That being said, I can't say there isn't progress.

I did learn to be proud of how much I care and try to show that I do. I don't always show it, but I try.

I... did kind of write this whole thing, alt text and all, didn't I?

My own story where I write about my emotional blockades through chraracters and situations... It exists. I haven't written anything in months, but it still exists.

I still do almost 100 tickets everyday, and I do as much house chores as I can. My health is improving... We don't talk about my diet though, yet.

Which is why I like the way the zone looks nowadays. After a specific quest, the computer running the simulations is turned back on, without the simulacra present this time. As a memorial to those who left and their legacies.

The same image of the city, the sky is still clear, but the building once again looks alive in gold. The gold color is no longer oppressively obscuring any other color in the frame, but complementing everything

The cutscene where we return to Living Memory and turn on the "computers" comes and goes in my head, embedded below with a timestamp to reference the scene in question.

It's Graha's phrase that gets me. Granted, in that scene in particular, he is talking about the difference between your first and second visit to the area and how the simple fact that you're going to essentially another dimension is mundane and calm. (Long Story, go play if you're interested.)

But the idea that the curse of experience is how life is supposed to be, the accumulation of the happy and the sad times, it was somehow comforting.

Helps that my favorite zone now feels less like walking through a graveyard, and I can hang about without feeling the melancholy swallow me whole.

Dawntrail had its flaws, but it captured that small part of my feelings in a potent little bottle and helped me face myself, even if briefly.

When Monday comes, I probably won't have the time or energy to entertain these thoughts, the weight of demand, routine and burnout will probably take my mind again and all I'll care about is surviving the day.

But in these moments where I stop and look at this city, so full of bygone lives... When I hear the track again... When I stop to think about these things that I regret. When I take walks to keep my sanity (and body) in a healthier state.

Maybe, one day, I'll get to the point where I stop cursing my experience on this earth so far.

One day, I hope to see these things I dropped and left behind... and be excited like I once was to pick it back up again.

A Screenshot from the game, with my character standing on a pier, looking up at the tower with the statue. Clear blue skies and the city alive with light again.