Dragon's Dogma 1 has always been one of those games for me that remain a mystery.

It has as many flaws as it has strengths, and the amount of explanation it gives about it's own systems is minimal, but the impact they have on your gameplay is profound. It sounds like a recipe for disaster nowadays, but at the time it just sounded like another Xbox 360 game, mediocre at best and a hyper-focused target at worst.

I either fell for the trap and it became my hyper focus, or maybe there was some of that gaming magic going with this game to captivate it's players.

Either way, I know I am not the only one.

It was a game that had side quests that were timed to main quest progress, a game where out of the box solutions generally worked, a game where asking "What if" usually meant a "Yes" if you tried. It was absolutely unique and to me, one of my favorites of all time.

The expansion, Dark Arisen, gave me a reason to keep grinding in Bitter Black Isle and amazing boss fights, but it was more within the common expectation of what a game is and should be. Played it safe, for lack of a better explanation, but did not lose their unique flavor.

In comes Dragon's Dogma 2 and a lot of the original DNA of the series that made it unique is still present! But now, the balance of flaws and strengths was a bit off.

Then the expansion, Dark Arisen, got announced for the second game and after playing it there is a lot going on in my head.

Both Dark Arisen expansions were not directed by Itsuno, the director for both Dragon's Dogma 1 and 2, and it shows in the way the game and expansion presents itself. Both expansions have the problem-solving the original games have, but they generally play it safe everywhere else; what felt like an adventure where you needed to pay attention now feels like a diet version, more forgiving and more "arcadey". An easier-to-digest Dogma flavor for a game.

The final boss of Dragon's Dogma 1 Dark Arisen, standing on the center of the image, his face darkened by the light shining from the broken dome on the roof, in what appears to be a destroyed throne room

Dragon's Dogma 2 Dark Arisen still does that, but also does a lot of what makes Dragon's Dogma 1 special as well. It feels like a much stronger middle ground between the two visions and it's honestly as close to perfect as either ever got to.

There's still issues, mostly born out of the clear difference of quality and content density between the expansion and the base game, but it is so good that when I finished the base game's main story again and entered New Game+ I immediately went back into Norgan to experience it once more.

It gave me the same itch that kept making me come back to Dragon's Dogma 1 base game and restart the tale of my Arisen, again and again. It was so effective in fact that I immediately re-downloaded Dragon's Dogma Dark Arisen to start a new play-through again.

I don't know a lot of games that set up this sense of adventure and, despite multiple re-runs, keeps itself fresh like this. But here it is, live and I get to play this, often.

And boy oh boy, there is a lot to play on this expansion.

A image of the Fallen Dragon, main antagonist of Dragon's Dogma 2 Dark Arisen. It's chest glows blue while below it, small humanoid creatures spill forth towards the two characters on the left and right corners of the frame.

A different approach to the main story and it's Dark Arisen

The original Dark Arisen told the tale of a revolt against the Dogma enforced by the seneschal, one where love, betrayal and seeing loved ones be denied their own will got the villain of that expansion to the point where they were. It a beautiful story, told in an infinitely repeating dungeon and this cannot be understated, given how much wiggle room they had to write an interesting tale, they hit the mark square on.

Dark Arisen 2 (Which is how I will refer to Dragon's Dogma 2 version of the expansion) takes a different approach to the story, one where the Dark Arisen has a main role to play but is done with much more depth than its predecessor.

We follow news about a new Arisen being spotted in Norgan, a snowy mountainous region in the northern area of Vernworth. The region has long since been abandoned by the crown due the barbarian tribes and harsh climate but once, both regions collaborated and flourished. This leads us, the... uh... original Arisen of this world to venture north to both understand how a second Arisen is possible and if they would be willing to help us overthrow the false Arisen in Vermund.

This simple premise will feel odd to returning players, because the Pathfinder is the one that eventually gives you entry to Norgan itself via a Gryphon it revives and commands to taxi you to the northern mountains.

And why in the flying fuck did he do that for?

The Pathfinder, shrouded in long robes and a ghostly light blue smoke. The scene is iluminated by a candle, while the extends his hand forward in a offering motion.

This guy wants you to fulfill your role as the Arisen that slays the Dragon and yet he approves of this complete side track to go after the Norgandian Arisen? And an Arisen that may have completely failed and is out-of-the-cycle per say? This attitude is odd but even this simple little feeling of confusion is used later on used in the story, leading it to never feel forced as a "We just needed an excuse to justify you coming here".

Once you get to Norgan though, things happen very fast.

You're quickly introduced to the last settlement of the region, a family of 6, and are granted a general goal of investigating mysterious rumblings plaguing the region that seem to come from the stronghold further north.

The family are the only actual town that you will see for the entire expansion, as such the personalities need to be pretty good since they will be the grand majority of the characters you interact with. And they surely delivered! They are all deep enough that you can actually see a character arc with almost all of them. Which is a piece of compliment I can also expand to all characters you meet in the Northern Mountains.

The tale about this Arisen that fell out of the cycle is one that is much more compelling than Dark Arisen 1, and it concludes that much more satisfyingly thanks to well-written characters that feel deeper than anything in the base game.

It's thanks to the freedom and limited information between known history and the current Norgandian inhabitants that my second favorite part of the expansion starts.

Eir, looking up to the sky while he face is bathed in pale glow. The mountain terrain around her is dark and she is clad in armor equipped for cold enviroments.

E X P L O R A T I O N

Norgan will look small on the map, but it certainly doesn't feel like it. The main difference here is the density of things to do. As you explore and get used to the lay of the land, there are caves, big creatures to fight, obelisks, and shortcuts to find and enable, so the simple act of walking around never feels unrewarding. Especially given the new artifact system, which basically works as your run-of-the-mill Destiny loot pool from items. It is nothing innovative, but it is executed well enough that it does certainly feel good to progress through the tiers of equipment and map, since they are tied together.

That isn't to say the relics you find aren't interesting, the perks allow for creative builds, and you get just enough to be fun to farm but not trivialise the process of gathering them.

The main settlement in Norgan, a small nordic village sorround by green and yellow tress and lush land, slitghly covered by melted snow and a bonfire on the center of the village

By far, my favorite feature of the expansion is just marking fights of all sizes on the map. This lets me directly figure out a route for fighting or when I am just trying to peacefully walk around the map.

The enemy variety also helps, while the common variety of enemy still feels pretty basic the Beorcans fill the void that thugs leave behind and all major monster fights are unique and well thought of, reminds me of the way Monster Hunter presents variants. It may be the same beast but the small differences make the fights unique enough that it does not become a problem.

The expanded skills slots and new skills you get from obelisks (and the extra upgraded version you get as perks from relic gear) also provide plenty of change and experimentation that traversal and combat don't feel too samey as base Dragon's Dogma 2

The biggest point, for me, is the ability to forever stay in the end game of the expansion, despite the main story progression. You see, in original Dragon's Dogma 2 you can only stay in the end game area for a limited time. But in Norgan, once you beat the main story, you can re-enter the expansion's end game anytime you'd like and stay there too. You'll want to do this too because farming all the fights (Yes, including the expansion's final boss!) is how you get the best gear possible from relics.

All of these elements combine to make what feels like the most interesting map in Dragon's Dogma overworld to explore, leagues above what was available in Dragon's Dogma 1 and 2 base game. It is beautiful to see, densely packed with curiosities and rewards, combat feels fresh, and it culminates in set pieces for the main story that are the new bar for what a good Dragon's Dogma is.

Which... is why I also find myself a bit torn on the current state of the game as a whole.

Creative visions and expectations

Personally, I am of the idea that a solid creative vision will tend to be more interesting for me than what is known and expected. Mind you, there is nothing wrong in seeking to satisfy a need for something in particular but when it comes to creative works such as books, movies and etc I tend to be more in line with the idea of "Try shit out and see if anything sticks". Which is why Dragon's Dogma 1 stuck, it had this genuine effort to create an adventure without having the player be giving all the pieces all the time. Often, there were mechanics, quests, fights and more that were hidden out-of-sight and only available for people who were paying attention.

It was a game that rewarded attention and dedication with unique and memorable moments. And I think that the base game of Dragon's Dogma 2 had that DNA in it, but it felt undercooked.

A picture of the Checkpoint Rest Town, a collection of houses along side a gate in carved into the mountain itself.

Between the stiff oxcart locations, limited teleporting and the sprawling map, I always felt that the game did reward paying attention but had very little to offer moment to moment and as a satisfying prize for doing what the game wanted you to do. This then boiled over to other cracks in the armor of the game, of which there were many.

The lack of enemy variety, few main quests, a huge map with disappointing rewards, shallow characters that followed simple arcs, unfocused story.

The issues were many, but not impossible to solve, as Dark Arisen 2 tackles a lot of them and shows a lot of good results. But it is almost like the base game and the expansion are borderline separate games when it comes to how they play together, and the difference is so jarring that it is impossible to ignore. It is to such a point that combat becomes a joke (Even on Hard Mode) in Vermund after progressing in Norgan.

The only real addition to the base game is the Lost Rites, which are fun dungeons that have interesting choices and puzzles, but the rewards only really work before Norgan comes in and as cosmetic unlocks for the visual of your Arisen, so it falls... a bit flat in a way. Almost like it is Beta testing the rewards from Norgan, but it comes so late into the base game that it does not flow well into the expansion content itself.

So I find myself loving Dragon's Dogma 2 vanilla for its potential AND loving Dark Arisen 2 for meeting the expectations of that potential, while completely ignoring the base game to my dismay. I wanted the adventure in Vernworth to expand further, to reach the same level of quality I see in Norgan, but that may not be possible since the person who originally helped shape that version of the game is no longer working at Capcom, for better or worse.

So I am left with a passable base game, with an expansion that is so fulfilling and deep that I mourn what the base game could have been.

It's an odd feeling to see the disparity of the original work and the new team that nailed the concept but end of the day, I am glad to be here. Norgan and Dark Arisen are great and a very hopeful step into what I hope are more Dragon's Dogma.

It is very worth your attention, and I hope more people are willing to give it a shot, even if it is just to play the expansion.

An overview of a castle fortress covered in snow, sorrounded by flying creatures. A woman with a sword and shield stands to the right, somberly looking over the scenery

To sum it all up...

Dark Arisen 2 upgrades everything that made Dragon's Dogma 2 good and does so by building itself on the same rules, but just far enough outside the orbit of the base game's infamy that it can stand on its own.

Like two properties that share land, they have similar materials, but the overall final result is vastly different. And I still loved every second of it.

Combat is renewed with a loot system that builds on a satisfying loop of looking for materials and that perfect roll of a weapon or armor. The enemies you fight will push your knowledge of the game and its systems to the limit, this is Dragon's Dogma after all, and it is all the more rewarding for it. The repeatability and perpetuity of the End Game are my wet dream and thanks to a technicality, you can also stay in the base game's final state for whoever long you'd like. Albeit, there isn't much to do there, as the rewards are not really compatible in its majority, and you'd also likely be absolutely destroying the entirety of all the challenges the base game has to offer, even with the addition of the Lost Rites.

It brings me hope that in the future, a Dragon's Dogma 3 starts with this much momentum, and not on the back foot like its predecessors.